From Charity to Solidarity: What Does It Mean to Stand With Those Experiencing Poverty?
Jessica Dewhurst
At the recent Presentation Movement Gathering in Minneapolis, one of our speakers mentioned the South African Dominican priest and theologian Albert Nolan. As a South African myself, his name was familiar to me, but something about hearing his work spoken about within the context of our Presentation mission stayed with me.
I found myself returning to his reflections afterwards, particularly his description of four stages of spiritual growth in our relationship with people experiencing poverty: compassion, structural change, humility and solidarity.
It struck me that these four movements offer us something more than a way of thinking about poverty. They invite us to examine how we respond to injustice, how we understand our role in the lives of those experiencing it, and ultimately what it means to live the Gospel call to stand alongside those pushed to the margins.
And as I reflected on Nolan's words, I kept thinking about Nano.
Stage 1: Compassion - We see suffering, and we respond
Nolan begins with compassion. We encounter another person's suffering and something within us says: This cannot be right. I have to do something. This is a response deeply familiar to the Presentation story.
Nano Nagle walked the streets of Cork and saw poverty around her. She saw children denied education and families struggling to survive. She could have looked away. Instead, what she saw moved her to action.
That same compassionate response continues throughout the Presentation world today. In schools, community programmes, shelters, parishes, advocacy initiatives and countless other ministries, Presentation people respond every day to those experiencing poverty and exclusion. We feed. We educate. We accompany. We provide resources. We open doors. These acts matter enormously.
But Nolan challenges us not to stop there. Because eventually compassion must lead us to another question: Why?
Why is this person hungry?
Why is this child unable to access education?
Why does this family not have a safe home?
Why are women disproportionately affected by poverty?
Why do some communities experience generation after generation of deprivation while others continue to accumulate extraordinary wealth?
Compassion sees suffering. Justice asks what is causing it.
Stage 2: Structural Change - Why does poverty exist?
This brings us to Nolan's second stage: structural change.
At this point, our focus begins to move beyond responding to the consequences of poverty towards confronting its causes.
We begin to recognise that poverty is not simply the result of individual circumstances. It is also shaped by economic systems, political decisions, discrimination, unequal access to land and resources, gender inequality, conflict, environmental destruction and structures that determine whose voices are heard and whose are ignored.
And this changes the questions we ask.
It is no longer only, How can we feed people who are hungry?
We must also ask, Why are people hungry in a world capable of producing enough food?
It is no longer only, How can we help this family find somewhere to live?
We must also ask, Why is safe and adequate housing inaccessible to so many?
It is no longer enough simply to respond to injustice. We must be willing to challenge the structures that continually recreate it. This is where charity begins to become justice.
For IPA, this is particularly significant. Our advocacy exists because the experiences we encounter in communities cannot remain only in those communities. They must reach the places where policies are written, decisions are made and systems can be changed.
But Nolan does not allow us to become too comfortable here either. Because even when we recognise structural injustice, there remains a danger that we still imagine ourselves as the people with the answers.
Stage 3: Humility - Learning to listen
The third stage is perhaps the one that challenges me most: humility. Those of us working in development, ministry, advocacy and human rights can very easily fall into the trap of believing that because our intentions are good, we know what other people need.
We design programmes, we develop strategies, we write submissions, and we advocate for people. And sometimes, without even realising it, the very people whose lives are most affected become recipients of our solutions rather than authors of them. Nolan challenges that relationship.
People experiencing poverty possess knowledge that those of us outside their experience simply do not have. They understand their communities, their struggles, their strengths and the barriers they face in ways that cannot be learned from a report or a set of statistics.
Our task, therefore, must begin with listening. This is something we are trying to place increasingly at the heart of IPA's advocacy: community listening before international advocacy. Before we decide what needs to be said at the United Nations, we must ask communities what they need the United Nations to hear. Before we advocate for change, we must ask those most affected what change should look like. And after advocacy has taken place, we must return to those communities.
Humility requires us to recognise that expertise does not only exist in universities, government offices, NGOs or UN meeting rooms.
Lived experience is expertise too.
Stage 4: Solidarity - There is no "us" and "them"
And then Nolan brings us to solidarity. Perhaps this is the most difficult movement of all because it asks us to let go of the distinction between those who help and those who are helped.
There can be a subtle danger in the language of service: We serve them, we speak for them, we give to them. Even with the very best intentions, an invisible line can remain between the giver and receiver, advocate and beneficiary, privileged and those made poor.
Solidarity asks us to erase that line. It does not romanticise people experiencing poverty or pretend that any group of people is without complexity, disagreement or weakness. Instead, it recognises something far more fundamental: We belong to one another.
As I reflected on Nolan’s understanding of solidarity, I found myself thinking about Ubuntu, the African philosophy meaning, “I am because we are.” Ubuntu reminds us too that our humanity is bound together - that I cannot be fully human while the dignity and humanity of another are denied. Solidarity, then, is not simply choosing to stand with someone else; it is recognising that their wellbeing, dignity and liberation are inseparably connected to our own.
Your dignity is connected to mine. Your freedom is connected to mine. The injustice that harms your community concerns me not because I have chosen to be charitable, but because our humanity is inseparable. And perhaps that is the deepest transformation Nolan asks of us.
We move from “I see your suffering and I want to help” to “I recognise the structures causing this suffering and I want them to change”. We then move onto “I realise I do not have all the answers, and I need to listen” to finally “Your struggle for dignity and justice is our struggle. We walk together”.
Carrying Nano's lantern today
I keep returning to the image that has accompanied the Presentation story for generations: Nano's lantern. We often speak about carrying Nano's lantern into the dark places of our world. Perhaps Nolan invites us to think a little more deeply about what carrying that lantern means today.
Perhaps the lantern does not only enable us to bring light. Perhaps it also enables us to see more clearly. To see beyond the immediate need to the structures creating it. To see the dignity, wisdom and agency of people whom society too often defines only by what they lack. To see when our desire to help has become a desire to lead rather than to listen. And ultimately, to see beyond the categories of us and them.
Nano did not simply observe the suffering around her. She allowed what she encountered to change the direction of her life. Perhaps that is the invitation before us too. As Presentation people, may we always have the compassion to respond when we encounter suffering. May we have the courage to challenge the structures that create injustice. May we have the humility to listen before we speak. And may we grow into a solidarity deep enough to recognise that the work for a more just world is not something we do for others. It is something we do with one another.
Because in the end, there is no us and them.
There is only us.






Comments